The Large Learn: The Sports activities Hub nightmare – what went fallacious in accordance with insiders, and might the federal government deal with it higher?

One other instance of a profitable area is England’s Wembley Stadium, says Matt Rogan, a British writer and sports activities marketing consultant.

The world is run by the Soccer Affiliation (FA) in England and is run in the same means as a social enterprise, which receives each private and non-private funding.

However not like within the case of SHPL, the place the Singapore authorities units its key figures, the FA itself is main the Wembley mission.

“Finally, there’s a choice maker, the FA is accountable for how it’s run, and the individuals who work to ship the industrial duty for the world all report back to the identical CEO,” Rogan stated.

“Each pound of revenue they earn is put again into rising the sport of soccer.”

He added that England’s native authorities solely set the FA’s intangible targets, reasonably than financial ones.

Such objectives might embody handing over to the FA to extend the variety of ladies taking part in soccer in England.

However Rogan acknowledged that soccer in England has a big and steady viewers base, which might imply that it’s not a threat issue to cut back ticket revenues.

One other instance of a profitable sports activities complicated is the Enviornment in Los Angeles, the house area of the Nationwide Basketball Affiliation (NBA) staff Los Angeles Lakers, in addition to a number of different sports activities resembling ice hockey and boxing.

Mr Marc Lim, a sports activities marketing consultant and former journalist, stated the world has been in a position to generate vital guests every day as it’s situated “proper within the coronary heart of Los Angeles”, with workplace house close by as effectively.

In Singapore’s case, renting out extra non-sports-related workplace house on the Sports activities Hub and constructing extra workplace buildings across the space would additionally assist make the realm extra full of life, he stated.

“One in all my distractions about Sports activities Hub and the Kallang space is that it’s so near city and so near the central enterprise district, (but) one of many issues that Sports activities Hub did not do was day by day visits to its companies there,” Mr Lim stated.

However there are additionally a number of sports activities venues all over the world that haven’t reached their industrial objectives, such because the London Stadium, which was constructed particularly for the 2012 Olympic Video games.

The stadium is said to a public-private three way partnership, which is owned by each a non-public industrial entity and the British authorities. Due to this association, “the stadium didn’t attain its potential,” Rogan stated.

“There are totally different stakeholders concerned, and it grew to become very political. Which means that they aren’t versatile or quick sufficient to develop the world for the long run “, he added.

The power thus misplaced many industrial alternatives, resembling serving different sporting occasions. For instance, Tottenham Hotspur Stadium in London, which opened in 2019, has a retractable soccer pitch with a synthetic turf beneath, which might then accommodate different sports activities resembling American soccer.

Nearer to house is Beijing’s Hen’s Nest Stadium, which was constructed particularly for the 2008 Olympic Video games.

Professor Simon Chadwick, a sports activities marketing consultant and international sports activities professor at Emlyon Enterprise Faculty in France, stated the stadium was constructed and initially run by the Chinese language authorities to serve predominantly “political functions”, reasonably than industrial ones.

“This was actually a show asset created to mission Chinese language energy,” he stated. “It was not created to function as a enterprise and meet the wants of the market.”

He stated that after the Olympics, the world turned out to be too removed from town middle for many vacationers and locals to go to.

“There isn’t a explicit purpose to go there apart from if there’s an incident,” stated Prof Chadwick, including that it was solely 5 to 6 years later {that a} non-public administration firm took over operations at Fågelboet.

“One of many issues that the non-public administration firm has had a tough time with is attracting the type of occasion to the venue that might make individuals truly spend time touring to truly see that occasion.”


One purpose that SportSG cited for the takeover of the Singapore Sports activities Hub is the elevated competitors within the area, as new sports activities amenities are being developed in different Asian capitals.

In Southeast Asia, the Sports activities Hub is head and shoulders above different arenas for the time being, stated the sports activities consultants who have been interviewed.

Mr Walton stated: “New arenas are being inbuilt international locations resembling Cambodia and Indonesia, for instance, however realistically, for main worldwide occasions such because the World Athletics Championships … Singapore has a significantly better place than Indonesia and Cambodia, and in a greater place than cities like Kuala Lumpur and Bangkok when it comes to positioning on the worldwide stage. ”

Lim agreed and stated that the closest rival could possibly be Kai Tak Sports activities Park in Hong Kong, which will probably be accomplished in 2023 and can embody a stadium with 50,000 seats and an indoor sports activities middle with 10,000 seats.

“Hong Kong, which is sort of cosmopolitan, (can) entice Rugby Sevens,” he stated, referring to the annual competitors often held on the Sports activities Hub.

However in terms of bidding on main occasions such because the World Athletics Championships and the ATP tennis finals, Singapore truly competes with different main cities all over the world.

“Once you have a look at the present World Cup bids, Singapore competes not solely towards cities within the area however globally resembling Los Angeles, New York, London, Cape City and Dubai,” says Walton.

“You need to be on high to problem in these conditions and actually, it’s tough to position aggressive bids if not all key stakeholders resembling SportSG, Singapore Tourism Board, Financial Improvement Board and area operators are in line,” he added.


With SportSG desirous to run the Sports activities Hub for the “social good” by having extra community-centered occasions, extra working prices are inevitable, enterprise lecturers had instructed TODAY earlier.

Nevertheless, there could also be different prices to bear when it comes to popularity and effectivity as effectively, the sports activities consultants stated.

Mr Lim stated he didn’t count on the stadium on the Sports activities Hub to be made as accessible to the general public as the opposite stadiums in Singapore, “the place everybody can stroll and run on daily basis”.

Nonetheless, its popularity as a world-class assembly place might be affected by extra neighborhood occasions being held there, with put on and tear changing into an element. “The very last thing you need is for the world to actually be a neighborhood health club, as a result of we’ve all these across the coronary heart … it ought to nonetheless be a premium expertise for the Nationwide Stadium,” added Mr Lim, who believes SportSG will put aside particular days for Sports activities Hub for use by the general public.

Leave a Comment

A note to our visitors

This website has updated its privacy policy in compliance with changes to European Union data protection law, for all members globally. We’ve also updated our Privacy Policy to give you more information about your rights and responsibilities with respect to your privacy and personal information. Please read this to review the updates about which cookies we use and what information we collect on our site. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our updated privacy policy.